Christina Applegate Nervously Addresses Ditching Brad Pitt Mid-Date For

“Vacation” star Christina Applegate wouldn’t kiss and tell during an appearance on Andy Cohen‘s “Watch What Happens Live”.

Answering questions posed during Cohen’s infamous, but always amusing, “Plead the Fifth” feature, Applegate shared even more TMI than her fans might suspect of an actress who starred in a film called Sweetest Thing.

Christina Applegate and Brad Pitt went on a brief date in 1989, but the actress left midway through the evening for another man!

“You had your fifth”, Cohen replied as Applegate’s fellow guest, Mark Consuelos, looked on in sheer delight. “Have you ever taken a dip in the lady pond?” “No, that’s not my cup of lady pond”, she responded.

“I have to plead the fifth on that one”, said Applegate.

Unfortunately for Applegate, Cohen had left the best question to the end!

“There’s much talk of a date you were on with Brad Pitt to the MTV Movie Awards in 1989 in which you reported that you ditched mid-date”, Cohen explained. “The question is, who was the guy you ditched Brad Pitt for?”

‘My question is who was the other guy you ditched Brad Pitt for?’ the Bravo exec added.

Applegate clearly wasn’t prepared to answer this question as she squirmed a bit before asking, “How many fifths do I get?”

Andy continued to try to pressure Christina to answer, but she was stubborn.

She used her pass when asked about which of her co-stars was the most well-endowed, which meant that when Cohen inquired about the Pitt debacle, she had to answer.

But when Cohen asked her which of the men she’d played opposite (citing her Vacation costarChris Hemsworth as an example) had had the biggest bulge, Applegate went coy.

So, there you have it: Applegate’s lips remain sealed.