Google Loses Bid to Overturn Low-Cost Patent Licenses To Microsoft

That means that electronics manufacturers could now pay lower rates to license a number of technologies commonly featured in smartphones and computers.

The court also upheld US$14.5 million (RM55.503 million) awarded to Microsoft for Motorola’s breach of contract to licence its patents fairly.

Google appealed the verdict and the royalty rate to the 9 Circuit.

These patents covered a range of technologies relating to Wi-Fi and video downloads. “Motorola took issue with that decision in part because Microsoft was able to introduce the lower court’s calculated patent licensing rate to the jury”.

Now that the decisions of both district court judge and jury have been upheld by the 9th Circuit, it’s a sure thing that big companies will think twice before using standards-essential patents against their competitors.

New york city In an obstacle for Google Inc (GOOGL.O), a You can include.S.is attractive legal procedure controlled on Thursday the fact that the low certification ratio Microsoft Corp (MSFT.O) makes sense to dip into the stash of Google’s Motorola Mobility asset appeared to be accurately set up.

Google originally asked for $4 billion. The lower court judge conducted a bench trial to determine a fair licensing rate, which ended up being a fraction of Motorola’s original request.

The case drew interest from a wide variety of players in the tech industry.

Apple, Intel and other companies filed court papers in support of Microsoft’s position, while major patent licenser Qualcomm opposed Robart’s calculation, saying it will devalue patents and cause “incalculable damage” to innovation.

The appeals court decision that was in favor of Microsoft might affect any future cases in patent licensing under similar terms. There’s also the matter of a connected lawsuit that still has to run its course.

Join the PC World newsletter!